Sec. 351 Exchange Offers Power Tool for Managing Tax Liability & Restructuring Stock Portfolios
IRS Scrutiny Demands Careful Compliance
For investors looking to diversify their investments tax deferred, IRC Sec. 351 provides an exchange method that enables a tax-deferred transfer of securities to be exchanged for interest in a newly launched ETF. Any taxes on subsequent gains are also deferred.
It’s important to note that taxes are only deferred, not eliminated. But the value of further diversification and the long-term tax deferral is a powerful tool for managing tax liability and restructuring stock portfolios.
Sec. 351 exchanges are typically utilized by:
- High net worth investors with highly appreciated stock positions who want to diversify or restructure portfolios without triggering immediate capital gains taxes.
- Estate planning-oriented investors who may want to defer taxes while holding assets for heirs and receive a step up in basis.
- Investors who want to simplify portfolios by replacing multiple individual holdings with a single ETF share class.
- Investors who may use the strategy to transfer appreciated securities into a new ETF fund for succession planning purposes.
The Rules
Transferring assets through a Sec. 351 exchange is subject to strict IRS rules including:
- The stocks must be placed into a newly launched ETF so that the transferors together own at least 80% immediately after the transfer.
- The portfolio must meet IRS diversification rules. These require that one stock may not be more than 25% of the value of the assets being transferred in, and five or fewer stocks cannot be more than 50% of the value.
- The transferor and any co-transferors must receive stock only in exchange.
- No gain or loss is recognized as long as the transferors collectively maintain 80% control after the exchange.
- Basis generally carries over, meaning the tax liability is deferred, but not eliminated.
Advantages of a Sec. 351 Exchange
Because the assets in a Sec. 351 exchange are placed into a newly launched ETF, they gain the advantages that an ETF provides. ETFs have a unique advantage in that they can trade stocks within the ETF tax-free. For example, if an individual investor trades their Nvidia stock, that’s a taxable transaction. But if the Nvidia stock is placed inside an ETF, it can be traded with no tax liability.
This helps make a Sec. 351 exchange particularly advantageous for investors who have portfolios with highly appreciated stocks. By placing them within a single ETF and ensuring their management is aligned with the investor’s goals and risk tolerance, the investor can benefit from tax-free trading.
Sec. 351 exchanges also offer estate planning advantages for investors, since the assets receive stepped-up basis at the time of the owner’s death, providing significant savings to heirs.
Current Controversy
Out of concern for aggressive use of Sec. 351 exchanges, the IRS has recently warned that it will increase scrutiny on certain types of Sec. 351 exchanges, which it views as an attempt to avoid taxes. The IRS has issued guidance stating that certain types of exchanges “don’t work under existing law.”
If the IRS finds that an investor has used an inappropriate mix of assets in a Sec. 351 exchange or has put together a portfolio with an inappropriate risk profile, or has otherwise run afoul of the rules, it can determine that certain stock contributions to an ETF are taxable.
Given this extra scrutiny and the potential for taxation and penalties, working with advisors who are experienced with Sec. 351 exchanges is essential to ensure compliance with strict rules and careful structuring of an exchange.
Questions?
Sec. 351 exchanges are a powerful tool for deferring tax liability, consolidating portfolio assets and managing diversification. But increased IRS scrutiny requires that investors ensure they are in strict compliance with the rules and that they work with advisors who are experienced at Sec. 351 exchanges.
If you would like to discuss whether a Sec. 351 exchange is appropriate for you, contact an Adams Brown Wealth Consultants advisor.

